Thursday, February 25, 2010

Week 7, Dialogue; "Shooting Dad"

"Luckily, both my parents grew up in exasperationg households where children were considered puppets and/or slaves".

This statement of Sarah's about her dad and mom tells the reader a lot about Sarah's relationship with her parents. When reading this essay, at first, it seemed that her dad and she were at odds with one another. Reading more closely I see where even though her dad was adament about how he felt about guns and his own political views, he gave Sarah and her sister the choice to explore their own set of beliefs and values. Certainly this was how Sarah developed her independence from her parents and becomes her own individual with a strong personality. Sound familiar?
Sarah, while growing up, I'm sure had some frustration as all children do in adolescence, with their parents, but we see in her essay how much she and her dad are alike, even with their differences. She even tells us that when older she decided to try "to figure out the whole gun thing". From her written essay and the audio, the love she has for her dad comes through and she respected his views and beliefs. At the end she wanted to light the canon and blow her dad's ashes into the hillside but this time she would not wear the earplugs because she wanted the noise to hurt her ears. I think Sarah wanted to feel and hear her dad's voice for the last time.

6 comments:

  1. Its really sad that it took that long for them to connect in some way. Even though she didn't like guns after just spending a little time with him shr finally realzed that the were a like.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I read the essay from this viewpoint as well. The family seemed to be respectful of differing opinions and allowed each member to have their own voice.

    I really like your last sentence it is powerful and very insightful.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree when I started reading the narrator was sharing how opposite her and her father was. It took awhile for them two to connect in something. If it wasn't for the cannon experience I think it would of took them a little more time

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Mary,

    I love the way you ended your post: "I think Sarah wanted to feel and hear her dad's voice for the last time." You use the sound of the canon as a metaphor for her father's voice. It's a wonderfully rich metaphor for her father.

    Lauren :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Marynicole,

    I really liked your point of view regarding the author. In the beggining the author felt she was totally different than the other members of her family and a loner only to find she was more like her father than she ever realized. It was great that the family allowed different viewpoints because in our family different viewpoints were great as long as they matched my parents. What an odd place to make a connection to bad as you say it was so late in life.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really liked the quote you chose from the story. I also liked how you explained everything in your paragraphs and how it really showed what you were talking about. Also, your opinion really helped in your writing and also the examples you used.

    ReplyDelete